Mad Libs

I don’t know if I’m dating myself, but I’m going to play a simple version of Mad Libs to ask some questions on morality:

____________ (Person A) commits a crime (murder, rape, torture – something that causes extreme physical harm to others) against __________ (Person B/Victim). __________ (Person C) knows about it, but covers it up. Should both ____________ (Person A) and __________ (Person C) be held accountable by the established legal system?

My guess is that most people who read this would generally say, “Of course.” Until you start filling in the blanks…

What if Person A & Person C are strangers and the Victim is a close family member? What if Person A or Person C is a close family member and the Victim is a stranger? What if that Victim is a known criminal or – egads! – a known terrorist?

What if Person A is George W. Bush and Person C is Dick Cheney?

What if Person A is Barack Obama and Person C is Joe Biden?

What if Person A is a pedophile priest, Person C is the Pope, and the Victim is a stranger? What if the Victim is a close family member?

What if Person A is a pedophile priest/minister at your church, Person C is that person’s immediate supervisor, and the Victim is a stranger? What if the Victim is your child?

What if you are Person A or Person C?

Funny thing is, many people’s answers to this Mad Lib change based on how you fill in the blanks. For me, this is a pretty simple question with a very simple answer: “YES.” Thinking critically will do that to you.

Of course, I can imagine some scenarios in which that “YES” answer won’t come so easily. After all, I’m only human (“Of flesh & blood I’m made…”).

About Luis Reinoso

was born and raised in Tulsa, Oklahoma to Peruvian immigrant parents. Growing up Roman Catholic in a staunchly Protestant Christian environment with a surrogate Jewish grandfather, he often questioned the logic of many religious practices. Traveling across the country and to other parts of the world opened his mind to different perspectives, further fueling his questioning nature. After recently retiring from the Navy after twenty years of active service, he has also recently made the decision to leave all forms of dogma, religious or otherwise, behind. He considers his greatest successes as those which came from his questioning of "conventional knowledge" and learning to confront his irrational fears. Separate from his involvement with the Center For Inquiry – DC, he enjoys film, music, travel, sports and reading. And, yes, he admits to being a Facebook junkie.
This entry was posted in Critical thinking, Politics, Psychology. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s